Core Beliefs: Supreme Being
Supreme Being as Abstraction
However, the intensity level of your belief even if it reaches all the way to the moon, changes nothing! I mention this only to point out that I do not accept “God said so!” as a logical argument in a debate. Have a great day!
Previously, it was my assertion that the idea of a “Higher Being” must be considered an abstraction. In light of receiving new information, I have decided to change my world view and concede that for some others, the idea of a “Higher Being” is considered as concrete reality. As a critical thinker that relies on facts, logic and reasoning, I now have no idea how I will proceed in debates with super religious fanatics!
To prevent misunderstandings and save myself time with explanations, I am providing common definitions regarding the ideas about a Supreme Being as an Abstraction. I have highlighted the areas that I relate to, the most.
Core Beliefs: Supreme Being
Supreme Being as Abstraction
Sent by you: Is the idea of God an abstraction?
Sent by ChatGPT: The idea of God can be considered BOTH an abstraction and a concrete reality, depending on the perspective or context in which it is discussed.
- As an Abstraction: For many, God is an abstract concept that represents ideals such as infinity, omnipotence, omniscience, or the ultimate source of meaning, existence, and morality. In this sense, God is an idea that goes beyond the physical world and is not tied to any specific, tangible form. This abstraction can manifest differently across cultures, religions, and philosophical systems, where God might symbolize absolute truth, justice, love, or the ultimate mystery behind the universe.
- As a Concrete Reality: For others, particularly within religious traditions, God is not merely an abstract idea but a concrete, living reality. In this view, God is a personal being with qualities and attributes that can be known, experienced, and related to. Many believers perceive God as actively involved in the world, with a distinct presence that can be encountered through prayer, ritual, and personal experience. In these contexts, God is MORE than an abstract idea; God is seen as a reality that can have a direct impact on individuals and communities.
- Philosophical and Theological Perspectives: Some philosophical and theological discussions approach the concept of God as both abstract and concrete. For instance, in certain branches of philosophy, God might be considered the “ground of being” (a term used by existential theologians like Paul Tillich) — the fundamental reality that makes all other realities possible. In such a framework, God is both abstract (as a concept beyond human comprehension) and concrete (as the ultimate source of existence).